BuzzFeed and our publishing partners may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Read More

Call us Nancy Drew, because we’ve finally solved the Mystery of Where to Find Shoes That Won’t Make Your Feet Ache.

I am a contributor and former editor who has been writing for BuzzFeed Shopping since 2020, where I'm focused on everything from home decor to beauty to where to buy the world's most comfortable high heels.

Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women's.

Pssst! It's recommended that you size up a half size in this shoe.

Promising review: "True to size, super comfortable, and no need to break them in! One of my most complimented pairs of shoes!" —Camille W.

"As soon as I put them on and started walking, I knew I had found my new go-to shoes. So comfortable and cute." —LuAnn R.

Get them from Seavees for $140 (available in sizes 5–11 and five colors).

Promising reviews: "I get so many positive comments on these shoes. They are so cute, but the best part is they are soooo comfortable! I thought the high heel back might be an issue, but it is not. They look the best without socks!" —NMW320

"Obsessed. Seriously, so comfortable and cute." —Hasters

Get them from Nordstrom for $119.95 (available in sizes 6–11 and three colors).

Promising reviews: "Nine months into wearing these at least twice a week to work, and they have held up beautifully. They are comfortable and practical, and the leather is soft and pliable. They haven’t been stained by water (e.g., walking through wet grass) and don’t show scuffs easily. They are the perfect leather boot that I was looking for to replace cheaper pleather boots that weren’t lasting more than six months without looking awful." —Amanda

"I have two pairs of these in nude and black. Both are super comfortable and easy to wear all day at work. I got the black perforated ones for summer, and they work well with low socks and keep my feet cool. I work in a place where the dress code is closed-toed shoes (government), and these look dressy, but aren't hot. Perfect." —Melanie H.S.

Get them from Amazon for $35.04+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide sizes, and 16 colors).

Promising reviews: "Love these boots. I was on the fence for months over buying them due to their high price tag. I’m glad I decided to try them. I got the 'black' color. They go with everything as they have a bronze tint to them that changes colors depending on what you’re wearing. They are super comfortable and fit perfectly." —Cingrl77

These fit perfectly true to size and are comfortable right out of the box. I chose this particular boot after looking far and wide for this style, but wanted a soft, distressed finish with a less severe cowboy heel, and wanted a toe shape that wasn’t pointed or perfectly round — this soft square shape is perfect. Wanted harness hardware that was not overdone, so I could ride the line between moto and Western, and the color looks dark brown and black at the same time. Very pleased with quality too." —KKVest

Get them from Anthropologie for $280 (available in sizes 5–10.5 and five colors).

Promising review: "I love these sneakers. Trendy throwback with comfort and style. True to size, looks good with jeans, sweats, and joggers. I wear them a lot, great price and quality. Highly recommend." —Cas

Get them from Amazon for $39.95+ (available in sizes 5–11 and six colors).

Promising review: "I was quite surprised by how comfortable this shoe is! It is versatile and can be used to dress up an outfit but is comfortable enough to walk around all day sightseeing. They do not look cheap. Wonderful casual shoe. I am ordering a second pair in a different color." —Loreena G.

Get them from Amazon for $22.99+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 12 colors).

Promising reviews: "I have these in two colors because they are such a great staple. Comfortable while giving an elevated look and feel. Love the beads on the brown pair." –Poppy

"The midnight blue is a beautiful shade. These sandals are very comfortable. No breaking in." —Lsc57

Get them from Madewell for $95.50+ (originally $118+; available in sizes 5–12 and five colors; all colors not available in all sizes).

Promising review: "I ordered these sandals hoping I would be able to wear them with no hesitation. The sandals are stylish, comfortable, and light. I really have enjoyed wearing them with my jeans and summer dresses. As I have gotten older, my feet have become very delicate, and I am always looking for comfort and style. I love my sandals and highly recommend them." —Yvette

Get them from Amazon for $32.99+ (available in sizes 5.5–11 and 11 colors).

Pssst! It's recommended you go a half size down from your usual size.

Promising review: "I loved them, they are super comfortable, and I thought they were going to be very heavy, but they’re actually super lightweight." —Carol Canon

Get them from Amazon for $60+ (available in sizes 5–15 and two colors).

Promising reviews: "Aside from being stunning — the camera doesn’t do justice — the fact that they were comfortable without needing to be broken in immediately made them my go-to since unboxing!" —princessssss

"I love this ballet flat and have a number of pairs in leather, suede, and fabric. I have found that they wear well and have had no issues with them. They are comfortable right out of the box and look great with jeans or dressy pants. I can no longer wear heels, and these are the next best thing for me. I hope that Sam Edelman always offers Felicia." —English Rose

Get them from Sam Edelman for $100+  (available in sizes 5–14, two widths, and 12 colors/fabrics).

Promising review: "Love these shoes! Great traction and grip on all terrain. They are super comfortable, and I love that the removable insole offers two different fits in one shoe! For longer distances, I like to take it out as my foot will swell. For more techy terrain, I put it back in for more absorption and cushioning. These shoes feel balanced and super stable. Highly recommend!" —Alexa

Get them from Backcountry for $159.95 (available in sizes 6–10 and two colors).

Promising review: "These are a perfect fit and feel like I am slipping my feet into butter. They are airy and cool. I tested them out and vacuumed and mopped the house in them. No sweaty feet, no slipping on the wet floor. They can go with anything. Dress them up with formal wear, throw 'em on with cutoff shorts and a tank top, a sundress, jeans and tee, anything, even PJs. They are shoes to travel in, fly in, and go to Disneyland in. They cover my whole foot, and I don't have to worry about missing the pedicure lady. They don't pinch. They are well-made, no threads or seams pinch or are stiff or give me pressure spots to cause blisters or soreness after hours of wear — it's like going barefoot. Get a little dirt on them, and they just wipe right off. I will definitely be buying another pair from this company. For the price, they are worth it." —hotmdc

Get them from Amazon for $23.99 (available in sizes 5–12 and nine colors).

Promising review: "The fit of these is amazing. The versatility is amazing. The cuteness is beyond anything other than cute. I get so many comments on them. They are comfortable, and I wear them all summer long. I have four different colors." —Heather Valley

Get them from Amazon for $29.99 (available in sizes 5–11 and 10 colors/prints).

Promising reviews: "I decided to splurge on these and am glad I did. They are amazing. Wore them all day. Very comfortable and beautiful. I got several compliments on them. So happy with this purchase." —Ofeliaa

"I bought both colors, thinking I’d choose the color I liked best, and I’m keeping them both. They’re soft and comfortable to wear all day or even around the house." —Free People Customer

Get them from Free People for $248 (available in sizes 6–11 and six colors).

Promising reviews: "These shoes fit true to size and are comfortable for everyday wear. The sole is thick, but they are super easy to walk in. They are a super easy way to dress up an outfit. I've gotten so many compliments on them. They are super comfortable while still being cute and not too old-fashioned looking." —Eden

"These loafers are so cute and so comfortable that they may be my all-time best buy in shoes. They are lightweight, and the heel is the perfect height and style for me for stability. But I will add again how comfortable they are because my feet can really be a pain in finding comfort. I am 74 years young and have put my poor feet through a lot. So it is not easy to find stylish shoes that I will wear. Buy them!" —RAG

Get them from Amazon for $26.99+ (available in sizes 6–11.5 and 10 colors). 

Promising reviews: "I bought these to take on a trip; they arrived, and I packed them without breaking them in — no worries, they are so comfortable, I wore them the whole trip. Love, love these shoes! This is my second pair. The first has lasted a year, and I wear the old ones still. They wash up nicely, too! Highly recommend!!!" —Lori M.

"Super comfortable from the moment I put them on — the cushioning and support are perfect for all‑day wear. The design is stylish and versatile enough to match with jeans, leggings, or casual dresses, and the build quality feels really durable. I’ve worn them for work, errands, walks, and long days out, and they hold up beautifully with no discomfort or rubbing. The traction on the sole is great too, so I feel confident in every step. For comfort, style, and everyday performance, these shoes are absolutely 5 stars!" —Whitney

Get them from Amazon for $19.95+ (available in sizes 5.5–12, including wide sizes, and six colors/patterns). 

Promising review: "I absolutely love my Rothy’s shoes! They are incredibly comfortable, stylish, and perfect for everyday wear. They look polished while still feeling lightweight and easy on my feet, even after wearing them for hours. I love them so much that I bought them in three different colors, including the leopard print, which is one of my favorites. They are versatile, easy to wear, and go with everything. Definitely one of my favorite pairs of shoes!" —Grace

Get them from Rothys for $149 (available in sizes 5–13 and eight colors/patterns).

Promising reviews: "I bought these shoes last minute for a wedding, and from the moment I slipped them on, I didn't think about them again until I slipped them off that night. They were so comfortable!! I walked through the park, gravel and grass, and they didn't slip off (even with nylons on) once!! I danced for hours in them, and my feet never hurt either. Amazing!! Can't wait to wear them again...maybe even to the airport!!" —Michelle

"Sooo comfortable and such a beautiful color." —Suzy

Get them from Target for $45 (available in sizes 6–11).

Promising reviews: "The best kitten heels ever. So cute and comfy." —Rosa

Get them from Urban Outfitters for $59 (available in sizes 6–10 and three colors; all colors not available in all sizes).

Promising reviews: "Very comfortable, stylish, and the color's amazing." —AncillynF356903429

"Veryyy comfortable and cute to match with everything." —Ashleyann524632652

Get them from Nike for $83.97+ (originally $115+; available in sizes 5–16.5 and 12 colors; all colors not available in all sizes).

Promising review: "Docs never disappoint. Fit..look..comfort are all super!! I would buy again, but this pair will probably last forever! So glad I got them!!" —Bella B.

Get them from Amazon for $157.04+ (available in sizes 5–11 and also maroon).

Promising review: "I have bought several of this style over the last 15 years. I have different colors, but the black is my go-to, especially for work. So comfortable and can walk for hours with no problem." —Mammacar

Get them from Fitflop for $65+ (originally $110+; available in sizes 5–11 and five colors).

Promising review: "I bought this sandal as a dressy sandal. It is so comfortable. I am wearing it now with jeans, dresses, and skirts. So glad I found it." —mari

Get them from DSW for $44.99 (available in sizes 6–11, medium and wide widths, and three colors).

Promising review: "These are comfortable right out of the box. I loved the adjustable Velcro straps that are located not only at the ankle but also the toe! The sole feels soft and dry, even after hours of wearing on a hot day. The tan color goes with all my summer outfits. I am ordering a second pair because I know these will become my go-tos for next year as well." —sammac

Get them from Lands' End for $89.95 (available in sizes 6–11 and three colors).

Promising review: "The best platform sandals ever! For a long time, I was looking for the perfect platform sandals. I have narrow feet and also a very sensitive arch. When I finally saw these ones, I decided to give them a chance, which was the best decision. They are comfortable, true to size, and lightweight, and also beautiful with the gold hardware. I got them in black and nude." —Xiomy

Get them from Old Navy for $29.99 (available in sizes 6–11 and two colors).

Promising review: "I couldn't wait for these to arrive, and I have not been disappointed. This is my first pair. They are so comfortable straight out of the box and so cute. This won't be my last pair." —Cheryl E.

Get them from Vivaia for $99+ (originally $139+; available in sizes 5–11 and 20 prints).

Promising review: "Perfect dress sandal. These shoes look so beautiful, the black looks very rich. The gold buckle is very nice. They are extremely comfortable with nice soft padding! I just am very happy with this purchase." —Coleen A.

"So classic and fun — but most of all, comfortable. I get so many compliments on these. Great with skirts or pants or shorts. The heels are a sweet spot, so appropriate for so many looks. Great quality, I love the buckle  it elevates the simple design without being too much. Highly recommend." —Shari P.

Get them from Aerosoles for $99 (available in sizes 5–11, including wide widths, and four colors; all colors not available in all sizes).

Promising review: "As with all Birkenstocks, these shoes are comfortable right out of the box. I have had problems with plantar fasciitis, and I have high arches. These shoes support my feet well without the need to wear orthotics, and I was able to walk miles on the first day I had them without any foot pain. I have fairly narrow feet, and these shoes fit me if I don’t wear socks, only when they are on the last setting of the buckle." —Lucy M

Get them from REI for $169.95 (available in sizes 36–42 EU and three colors).

Promising reviews: "Really pleased with this purchase — I wasn't sure if the soles would feel thin and how comfy they would be, but there's plenty of cushion and the leather is so soft that I feel like my feet are being hugged. I'll be wearing these nonstop this summer!" —JennyB.

"I was pleasantly surprised by these sandals. They’re extremely comfortable with soft leather straps and cushioned soles. So cute, too." —MeganP.

Get them from Quince for $92 (available in sizes 5–11 and three colors; the brandy color is only available on pre-order).

Promising reviews: "These shoes are amazing! They are so comfortable and true to size. I have very narrow feet, and they are adjustable for any width. Great arch support. They look so cute with pretty much anything from swimsuits to dresses." —robin s.

"These are the comfiest slip-ons. I originally bought them to use for when I go out to water the garden, but they’re so cute that I will wear them out. Like walking on little clouds. You won’t regret buying them." —Amazon Customer

Get them from Amazon for $21.99+ (available in sizes 6–11 and seven colors).

Promising reviews: "This is my first pair of Crocs, and I must say I am very pleased. I love the platform (chunky) look. Very comfortable and fashionable." —Ash

"Very comfortable and cute! Love that they give me extra height while still being comfortable." —Anonymous

Get them from Zappos for $42.24+ (originally $64.99+; available in sizes 4–11 and 12 colors/patterns).

* These 30 Shoes Are Stylish, Versatile, And Extra Comfy — AKA They’re Perfect For Taking On Trips

* Pairs Of Shoes Reviewers Say Stay Comfortable Even In Hot Weather Or When They Sweat

* Sandals Your Future Self Will Be So Glad You Bought At The Start Of Summer

* Comfy Shoes Reviewers Swear By For Their Daily Commute

Plus, finds from DSW, Nordstrom, and Walmart.

BuzzFeed Shopping is service journalism first: our writers and editors spend all day shopping so you don’t have to, vetting products, fact-checking brand claims, and surfacing what actually helps in real life. We center readers over revenue, recommend products with authenticity (using real experiences, not ad-speak), and reflect our diverse audience, inclusive of a variety of price points, people, and needs. We cut through fake deals, favor useful info over glossy fluff, and recommend both budget and splurge options with context so you can decide what’s right for you — and still have a little fun along the way.

Reviews for this post have been edited for length and/or clarity.